When should you renovate or replace an old post-frame building?

Renovating Post-Frame buildings can sometimes be tricky. In the world of construction, the question often arises – should you renovate an existing structure or start from scratch with a new building?

This decision can be particularly challenging when dealing with post-frame buildings, which offer unique opportunities and challenges due to their rustic charm and construction.

However, with the right approach and a comprehensive guide, reviving these buildings can be an incredibly rewarding endeavor.

It is crucial to understand the condition of your building. There are several factors to consider when deciding whether to renovate your post-frame building or build a new one:

1. Building Condition: The current condition of your building is crucial. If the structure is sound and the damage is minimal, renovation could be a more cost-effective choice. However, if they are structurally compromised to the point of being more expensive to fix than to replace, we highly recommend replacing the building.
2. Cost: Renovations can be less expensive than new constructions, especially if the existing structure is in good condition. However, if extensive repairs are required, building new might be more economical.
3. Time: Renovations typically take less time than constructing a new building. If time is a critical factor, renovation might be your best bet.
4. Historical Value: If your post-frame building holds historical or sentimental value, preserving it through renovation could be worth the additional costs and effort.

An inspection by our experts will help assess the building, before making any decisions on renovations.

It is important to have a clear vision for the desired transformation. Are you looking to create a cozy barn-style home, a spacious workshop, or perhaps a trendy commercial space? Understanding your goals will help you make informed decisions throughout the renovation process and ensure that the end result aligns with your vision. 

Here are several key factors to consider when renovating your post-frame building:

• Structural Integrity: Before starting any renovation work, let our experts at Milmar assess the structural integrity of your building. This will determine the extent of the renovations required. 
• Permits and Regulations: Check local building codes and regulations. Some areas have strict rules about renovations, particularly for older or historic buildings.
• Budget: Set a realistic budget that includes a contingency for unexpected costs as they happen frequently during remodel work once walls are opened up.
• Contractor Selection: When choosing a contractor with experience in renovating post-frame buildings, Milmar is the right choice for you. We provide valuable insights and recommendations throughout the renovations process and for permitting if needed.
• Design and Functionality: Consider the desired outcome of your renovation. Are you looking to update the building’s aesthetics, improve its functionality, or both? Our architectural and design expertise will help create a plan that meets your specific needs while maintaining the integrity of the original structure.
• Future Expansion: Think about your long-term goals for the building. Will it need to accommodate future expansion or changes in functionality? Incorporating flexible design elements during the renovation can save you time and money down the line.
• Timeline and Project Management: Develop a realistic timeline for the renovation. Regularly monitor the progress of the project and address any issues promptly to keep it on track.

Different upgrades for different purposes

It is good to consider the specific design elements that will contribute to achieving your desired outcome.

For a cozy barn-style home, you may want to incorporate rustic and natural materials such as exposed wooden beams, stone accents, and vintage decor. Consider an open floor plan to maximize the feeling of spaciousness while maintaining a warm and inviting atmosphere.

On the other hand, if you envision a spacious workshop, functionality and organization will be key. Think about installing storage solutions, sturdy workbenches, and efficient lighting. Also, consider the layout and flow of the space to optimize productivity and ease of movement.

If a trendy commercial space is what you’re after, focus on modern and sleek design elements. Use clean lines, contemporary furniture, and statement pieces to create a visually striking environment. Pay attention to branding and marketing opportunities to make your space stand out and attract customers.

Whatever the purpose for renovation is, it should be clearly communicated before the renovation process begins.

It is important to note: When thinking of renovating, the cost is ultimately crucial. In some ways, renovating is less costly than rebuilding, and at times, rebuilding is the more economical option than renovating. Our team will inspect the structure to identify how much wood framing needs to be replaced, and that is an important factor to be considered when it comes to cost. 

Design Your Post-Frame Barn or Garage With Milmar Buildings! 

Oftentimes, the roof re-skin doesn’t cost any more than the walls, unless you are replacing the wood trusses themselves. An upgrade frequently requested is adding overhangs to a building which had none, during the re-skin process, which you can also add house-wrap to control condensation on the roof and/or walls.

Is Renovation Worth It?

Renovation can indeed be a worthwhile endeavor. It can save money, time, and even contribute to sustainability by reusing existing materials. It also allows for the preservation of buildings with historical or sentimental value.

So, if you’re considering what to do with your post-frame building, don’t discount the power of renovation. With our help, you can breathe new life into your old building, creating a space that combines the charm of the past with the conveniences of the present.

Milmar is more than capable of assisting you with your post-frame building project. Speak with our experts today!

Originally posted on Aug 25, 2023